This image provided by scholastic shows the cover of the book a birthday cake for george washington by by ramin ganeshram. Whether you need a classic kids book or classroomproven teaching materials, discover it at scholastic. Just remember that whenever scholastic hypocritically pontificate against the banning of books during the next banned book week. Critics such as the school library journal argued that the book presented an unrealistically sunny portrait of slavery. Scholastic initially defended the book, saying that it took a nuanced but fair view. In january 2016, her childrens book a birthday cake for george washington, about u. After a torrent of criticism, scholastic has decided to stop distributing a birthday cake for. Criticized book on washington slave pulled mail online. Publisher pulls george washington kids book for upbeat portrayal of slavery. On january 5, scholastic released a birthday cake for george washington, written by ramin ganeshram and illustrated by vanessa brantleynewton. Scholastic is announcing today that we are stopping the distribution of the book entitled a birthday cake for george washington, by ramin ganeshram and illustrated by vanessa brantleynewton, and will accept all returns. Scholastic pulls a birthday cake for george washington.
On this page, writer ramin ganeshram cites a biographical fact that is omitted from the books central narrative namely, that washingtons. A birthday cake for george washington, by author ramin ganeshram and illustrator vanessa brantleynewton, is narrated by the daughter of george washingtons slave, hercules, who is preparing a cake for the presidents birthday. Under pressure, scholastic recalls racist childrens book. A birthday cake for george washington by by ramin ganeshram. The writer and journalist ramin ganeshram, who wrote a birthday cake for george washington, subsequently recalled by scholastic. Scholastic pulls childrens book criticized for depiction. The cover of the book a birthday cake for george washington by ramin ganeshram. Childrens book a birthday cake for george washington. Written by ramin ganeshram and illustrated by vanessa brantleynewton, the book was released on jan.
A firestorm erupted when scholastic released a childrens book early this month, a birthday cake for george washington, by ramin ganeshram and illustrated by vanessa brantleynewton, featuring smiling enslaved people baking a cake for george washington. Scholastic pulls childrens book criticized for depiction of happy. President george washingtons slaves who look for ingredients to bake a birthday cake for their owner, was published by scholastic. The book, written by ramin ganeshram and illustrated by vanessa brantleynewton, tells the story of washingtons slave cook hercules. Scholastic pulls a birthday cake for george washington amid slavery backlash the cover of the book a birthday cake for george washington by ramin ganeshram. Amid controversy, scholastic pulls picture book about. George washingtons birthday cake is an outstanding picture book for a young child. Ramin ganeshram is a veteran journalist who has written for many prestigious publications such as the new york times, newsday, national geographic traveler, and bon appetit, among others. But anjali must keep her wish a secret from her family, who thinks anjalis passions are beneath her.
A birthday cake for george washington is a childrens book published by scholastic and first released on january 5, 2016. Hercules was americas first celebrity chef, the book s editor argued argued, and the slaves were happy because they took pride in their work. Scholastic pulls birthday cake for george washington. A trinidadianamerican girls dream is challenged by her family thirteenyearold anjalis life is rich with the smell of curry from her parents roti shop and an absolute passion for food. The author of a childrens book pulled last month because of its smiling depiction of slaves says she objected to the illustrations and had. Childrens publisher scholastic has ceased distribution of a book that. Scholastic pulls book about george washingtons slaves. Childrens book paints slaves as happy bakers for george washington.
A firestorm erupted when scholastic released a childrens book early this month, a birthday cake for george washington, by ramin ganeshram and illustrated by vanessa brantleynewton, featuring. New statement about the picture book a birthday cake for george washington. The book tells the story of hercules and delia baking a birthday cake for washington. Scholastic ceases distribution of controversial picture book. Scholastic january 15th, 2016 over the past few days, a birthday cake for george washington, the new picture book by ramin ganeshram and illustrated by vanessa brantleynewton, has generated an important discussion about the depiction of slavery in childrens books. Slavery was a complex institution, and in fact, some slaves found happiness and pride in some of their tasks, ramin ganeshram, the author of the book. Scholastic pulls george washington book after slavery backlash. Ramin ganeshram says she expressed concerns to scholastic but.
A firestorm erupted when scholastic released a childrens book early this month, a birthday cake for george washington, by ramin ganeshram and illustrated by vanessa brantleynewton, featuring smiling slaves baking a cake for george washington. A novel by ganeshram, ramin and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at. January 17, 2016 scholastic is announcing today that we are stopping the distribution of the book entitled a birthday cake for george washington, by ramin ganeshram and illustrated by vanessa brantleynewton, and will accept all returns. Thirteenyearold anjalis life is rich with the smell of traditional trinidadian and indian foods and curries from her parents roti shop and an absolute passion for food. Selfcensorship of childrens book depicting smiling. Ramin ganeshram, wrote in an appended message in the book that hercules was eventually freed but his daughter. Scholastic is announcing today that we are stopping the distribution of the book entitled a birthday cake for george washington, by ramin ganeshram and illustrated by. Publisher pulls george washington kids book for upbeat.
While we have great respect for the integrity and scholarship of the author, illustrator, and editor, we believe that, without more. Scholastic withdraws george washington cake book from. More than anything, anjali wants to be a chef who competes on a kids cooking reality tv show. The author, ramin ganeshram, defended her work in a blog post. The book, written by ramin ganeshram and illustrated by vanessa brantleynewton, was published on jan. New statement about the picture book a birthday cake for. Scholastic pulls childrens book starring george washingtons. Written by ramin ganeshram and illustrated by vanessa brantleynewton, it is narrated by delia, the daughter of hercules, one of george washingtons slaves who worked for him as a cook. All purchases earn scholastic rewards for your nominated school. Ramin ganeshram, a former journalist for the new york times and forbes, penned the book. The author, ms ganesham, has taken great pains to show what life was like inside the washington household for slaves, but especially for an exceptionally talented chef. A birthday cake for george washington hardcover january 5, 2016 by ramin ganeshram author, vanessa brantleynewton illustrator scholastic press isbn.
The back cover portrayed george washington and his enslaved chef, hercules, arminarm, like best buddies. Shop at the scholastic store for the best books for children, educational resources for kids, crafts for kids, teachings resources and more. Scholastic is pulling a new picture book about george washington and his slaves amid objections it sentimentalizes a brutal part of american history. Scholastic pulls childrens book criticized for depiction of happy slaves. Ramin ganeshram says she expressed concerns to scholastic.
Scholastic pulls controversial george washington book. The store, the store, stir it up, anjali krishnanknows that the best recipes are those that let her express who she truly is a girl with an absolute passion for cooking. Scholastic pulls birthday cake for george washington book time. Why the banning of a birthday cake for george washington. Scholastic said in a statement the book may give a false impression. The childrens book authored by ramin ganeshram and illustrated by vanessa brantleynewton drew criticism for its pictures of smiling slaves the real hercules escaped to freedom on washingtons.
Visit scholastic, the worlds largest childrens book publisher. A birthday cake for george washington by ramin ganeshram. The publishers decision comes after the text, by ramin ganeshram and illustrated by vanessa brantleynewton, was criticized for its depiction of slavery. Ramin ganeshram born june 21, 1968 is an american journalist, chef and cookbook author. After outrage publisher pulls happy slaves childrens book. Childrens book recalled for superficial portrayal of slavery. Ramin ganeshram is an american journalist, chef and cookbook author who writes about american and caribbean foodways and culinary culture.
364 1326 166 1583 552 1085 977 1192 1299 830 794 80 1122 1168 792 1607 992 960 1467 895 1311 944 726 538 331 1176 577 1294 816 961